Find us @


New York City has said it welcomes migrants In reality, that is not the case

The city’s promise of sheltering those in need has hit a breaking point



The (Bloomberg) This week, buses of migrants from the Southern border sent by the governor of Texas kept arriving in New York City, putting to the test Mayor Eric Adams’s assurance that everyone is welcomed “with open arms.”

Most Check out Bloomberg

The migrants, however, who are arriving by the busload, are rapidly realizing that Adams’ encouraging remarks only serve to conceal a harsher truth: a city that can’t actually handle them.

Long regarded as a “sanctuary city,” New York won’t turn immigrants away or hand them over to authorities when they arrive. A lack of shelter or inexpensive housing choices, a convoluted and bureaucratic intake procedure, a lack of language and legal assistance, and an overworked NGO sector are obstacles that the most recent newcomers must deal with.

Corey Hayes, the creative director of City Relief, an organization that aids those who are homeless in finding homes and food, declared that “the city is simply not ready for this.” “Our city has a right to shelter, but that doesn’t mean you know how to get around it to really get into a shelter if you wanted to,” the speaker said.

More information may be found at NYC Mayor Slams Texas Governor for Busing Migrants to City Migrant Inflow

Greg Abbott, a Republican, has been sending buses of migrants from the Texas border to Democratic cities like New York and Washington, D.C. as part of a continuous effort to criticize Democratic President Joe Biden on immigration.

New York’s shelters were already having trouble keeping up with an inflow of migrants on top of a population that was already expanding before the buses arrived. In a letter written to Comptroller Brad Lander in July, Gary Jenkins, commissioner of the New York City Department of Social Services, stated that in the previous three months, about 4,000 asylum seekers had entered the system. 3,000 of them are believed to have arrived in July alone, according to Catholic Charities of the Archdioceses of New York, a nonprofit organization that supplies food and other essentials to immigrants and refugees in New York City.

According to a study released in March by the city’s Independent Budget Office, the Department of Homeless Services spent more than $3 billion last year, which is three times the budget from the previous year. According to the research, the city will need to raise funds for its housing voucher and shelter programs in the upcoming years.

Additionally, according to Monsignor Kevin Sullivan, executive director of Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of New York, the admissions procedure has been “chaotic.” He said that there was no organized strategy for their arrival.

Can Puerto Rico become a state? Image gallery The history of its interactions with the US is shown here. (Stacker)

One of five city-run intake centers is the place someone is told to go after getting off a bus. Then, before placing candidates in temporary housing inside one of five shelter systems or the 11 hotels that have recently been built up to house families, centers evaluate applicants to see if they have any friends or family members to live with. For at least 90 days, a person must reside in a temporary shelter to be eligible for one of the city’s rental aid programs for a more permanent residence.

Adrienne Adams, a City Council spokesperson, described how, on a recent night in July, four families were made to sleep on the floor of the intake office prior to receiving shelter placement, which was against the law.

She wanted further information from the administration about how it intended to meet the needs of the freshly arrived migrants, along with other members.

“This not only violates the city’s rules requiring shelter but also does these families irreparable pain. It is brutal and demeaning, and it goes against everything this city stands for, Speaker Adams added.

Late involvement of the mayor

Abbott has received swift criticism from Mayor Adams for treating individuals as “political pawns.” He has requested federal assistance from the Biden administration, just like Mayor Muriel Bowser of Washington, D.C. He also promised to assist newly arrived families, calling it the “duty” of the city when he met a bus of them at Port Authority last weekend. I have to offer services to the families who are present.

Adams declared an emergency on August 1 in order to “rapidly secure” more housing and services for the recent refugees. The city also intends to create a new building in midtown Manhattan that can accommodate up to 600 households temporarily. In order to better prepare for future immigrants, the city is also collaborating with the New York Immigration Coalition, according to Executive Director Murad Awawdeh, “so that we’re not at the last minute trying to create new systems, but having systems in place that are easily expandable or then retractable.”

Immigration advocates and a few City Council members, however, assert that the city is tardy in addressing a longstanding issue that has been putting further strain on an already precarious system. They contend that the city has not effectively addressed concerns relating to accessible housing, shelter choices, a lack of qualified employees, inadequate city funds, and administrative red tape.

Deborah Berkman, the organizing attorney for the New York Legal Assistance Group’s shelter advocacy campaign, which offers free legal assistance to persons who are experiencing homelessness, stated, “This situation was extremely foreseeable.” “New Yorkers are undoubtedly hospitable, and the mayor undoubtedly wants to welcome them. However, I do believe that the current method for securing shelter is already rather unwelcoming.

According to a 1979 ruling by the New York State Supreme Court, everyone in need of refuge must have access to a bed. Numerous groups and charities filled the gaps for years by assisting migrants and those who were homeless in finding food, clothing, and employment. The new inflow of refugees comes at a time when business is usually brisk for these professionals, whose caseloads were already heavy and are now near capacity.

Nonprofit organizations like Catholic Charities are attempting to mobilize fast in the interim. People are given food and clothing by the group, along with suggestions for day labor jobs.

The executive director, Sullivan, remarked, “My belief is that if we provide a modicum of help to these individuals immediately in the crisis, they will make it in New York and they will make New York better and more lively.”

Most Take a look at Bloomberg Businessweek.